Key takeaways
- There is no trustworthy single ROI figure for executive coaching; headline percentages usually come from self-estimates in industry-backed surveys.
- Meta-analyses report positive effects of coaching, strongest on behaviour, with gains in self-efficacy and resilience.
- Randomised trials with doctors found coaching reduced burnout measures, though some gains faded after coaching ended.
- Much coaching research is small, short and run by people with a stake in the field, so read it with care.
- The most useful ROI measure is personal: agree three observable outcomes before you start and review them at set points.
- If nothing measurable has shifted by the halfway point, change the plan or stop.
What is the ROI of executive coaching?
The honest answer is that nobody knows the return in money terms with any precision. Coaching does seem to produce real changes in how leaders behave and how they cope, and those changes plausibly affect results. Turning that into a reliable percentage would need large, independent trials that measure financial outcomes, and the field does not have them.
That matters because ROI claims are a common sales tool. You will see figures of several hundred per cent quoted online. When you trace them back, they usually come from surveys commissioned by coaching firms or professional bodies, in which coached leaders estimate the value themselves. Those estimates may be sincere, but they are not measurements.
None of this means coaching is worthless. It means you should judge my performance coaching, or anyone else's, by outcomes you can see in your own working life rather than by a number on a brochure.
What does the research say about executive coaching outcomes?
The research points in a positive direction with wide margins of uncertainty. Several meta-analyses, which pool the results of many studies, report that coaching improves outcomes for individuals and organisations. The details show where the effects are strongest and where the evidence thins out.
| Study | What it looked at | Main finding | Caveat |
|---|---|---|---|
| Nicolau et al., 2023 | 20 controlled executive coaching studies | Largest effects on behaviour; gains in self-efficacy, psychological capital and resilience | Mostly self-reported outcomes; no financial measures |
| Cannon-Bowers et al., 2023 | Updated meta-analysis of workplace coaching | Coaching achieves positive organisational outcomes, in line with earlier reviews | Lead author runs a consultancy; authors call the science immature |
| Dyrbye et al., 2019 | Trial with 88 physicians, six coaching sessions | Emotional exhaustion and overall burnout fell compared with controls | Doctors in the United States; small pilot |
| Dyrbye et al., 2023 | Trial with 80 surgeons, six monthly sessions | Burnout fell and resilience rose | Burnout drifted back within six months of coaching ending |
Two earlier meta-analyses are often quoted alongside these: one by Theeboom and colleagues in 2014 and one by Jones and colleagues in 2016, which pooled 17 studies of workplace coaching and reported positive effects overall. Neither is indexed on PubMed, but both are widely cited in occupational psychology, and the 2023 review describes its own results as consistent with earlier work.
Why is coaching ROI so hard to measure?
Coaching ROI is hard to measure because the benefits are spread across time, people and outcomes that rarely appear on a balance sheet. A director who handles one conflict better might keep a valued colleague, avoid a grievance and sleep better, and none of those gains carries a clear price tag.
- Small samples: many studies involve a few dozen people.
- Self-report: outcomes are often rated by the person who was coached.
- No comparison: plenty of studies lack a control group, so improvement could have happened anyway.
- Short follow-up: few studies check whether gains last a year later.
- Interested parties: researchers, funders and authors are often connected to coaching firms.
- Mixed definitions: coaching means different things across studies, from six calls to a year of meetings.
The CIPD makes a related point in its guidance for employers: coaching is one development option among several, it is not a universal answer, and it works better when it is evidence-based and used for the right needs. That is a sensible frame for anyone weighing the return.
Is executive coaching research funded by the coaching industry?
Often, yes, or at least it is carried out by people with a professional interest in coaching. That does not make the findings wrong, but it is a reason to read them with care and to give more weight to independent, controlled trials.
The 2023 workplace coaching meta-analysis is a good example. Its lead author is listed with a consulting firm, while the other authors are university psychologists. The authors are open about the field's weaknesses and argue that a true science of coaching has yet to be developed. I find that candour more persuasive than a large ROI figure.
The physician trials sit at the more independent end. They were run by a university medical centre's well-being programme, used established measures of burnout and compared coaching with a control group. Their limits are scale and setting rather than salesmanship.
How can you measure the ROI of your own coaching?
Measure it the way you would measure any investment of time: set a baseline, agree observable targets and review them on fixed dates. Personal ROI is easier to judge than organisational ROI, because you can see your own week clearly.
- Name the problem precisely.Write down what is happening now in terms someone else could observe, such as working three evenings a week or postponing a restructure since spring.
- Record a baseline.Count it for two weeks before coaching starts: hours worked, decisions deferred, meetings that overran, nights of poor sleep.
- Choose three outcomes.Pick changes that would matter to you and that you could verify, rather than broad hopes such as being more confident.
- Estimate the cost of the problem.Put a rough figure on what it costs if nothing changes: lost time, staff turnover, delayed revenue or health.
- Review at session four.Compare the numbers with the baseline and decide, with your coach, whether to continue, adjust or stop.
- Review again three months later.Check whether the change has held, since the physician trials suggest some gains fade without maintenance.

This approach will not produce a neat percentage, but it gives you an honest answer to the question that matters: did the time and money change something you care about?
If you want to set measurable aims before you spend anything, the free 30-minute call is a good place to start.
Book a free 30-minute callWhat outcomes can you realistically expect?
Realistic outcomes are changes in behaviour and coping that you can point to within a few months. The research supports that kind of expectation better than it supports dramatic claims about revenue.
| Area | Vague aim | Measurable outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Workload | Feel less buried | Two evenings a week free of email for six weeks |
| Delegation | Let go more | Three recurring tasks handed over with a review date |
| Decisions | Be more decisive | The postponed restructure decided by an agreed date |
| Conflict | Handle people better | The overdue conversation with a co-founder held and followed up |
| Recovery | Feel less stressed | Seven hours' sleep on most weeknights, logged for a month |
If stress has already tipped into exhaustion, the article on signs of burnout in executives explains what to watch for, and when to see a GP alongside any coaching.
How should an organisation evaluate coaching for its leaders?
An organisation should evaluate coaching against goals agreed at the start, using a mix of the leader's own report, observable behaviour and business indicators, while protecting the confidentiality that makes coaching work. Measuring only satisfaction with sessions tells you very little.
- Agree two or three development aims with the leader and the coach before sessions begin.
- Collect a baseline, such as feedback from colleagues or team turnover.
- Keep session content private; review outcomes, not conversations.
- Compare coached leaders with similar colleagues where numbers allow.
- Repeat the measures six to twelve months later.
For senior people booking privately, as many of my director clients do, the same principles apply on a personal scale.
What should you ask a coach about results before you book?
Ask how the coach defines progress, how they will review it with you and what they do when a programme is not working. A coach who answers these questions clearly is far more likely to give you a measurable return than one who points to testimonials or a headline percentage.
- How will the two of you agree the outcomes at the start?
- When will progress be reviewed, and against what?
- What happens if nothing has changed by the fourth session?
- Where does any ROI figure on your website come from?
- Which kinds of problems do you think coaching handles poorly?
The last question is revealing. Coaching suits behaviour change, decisions and resilience reasonably well. It suits structural problems, such as an unworkable business model or a hostile board, much less well, and an honest coach will say so before taking your money.
How I approach results with clients
I agree outcomes at the first session and revisit them at the fourth. If the work is not moving, I say so and suggest a change of approach or an end to the programme. I do not quote success rates, because I do not think private coaching data can support them honestly.
Since 2016 I have seen hundreds of clients across coaching and therapy, and my training includes Master Hypnotist (DMH) and EMDR Practitioner alongside NLP to Advanced Master Practitioner level. That background makes me cautious about overclaiming. The executive coaching page explains how programmes run, the how coaching works page covers the practical steps, and all prices are on the fees page.
If you want to weigh the wider evidence on coaching first, the articles does life coaching work? and how much executive coaching costs in the UK are useful companions to this one.
Sources
- Nicolau A et al. Executive coaching on behaviors, attitudes and characteristics. Frontiers in Psychology, 2023. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37333584
- Cannon-Bowers JA et al. Workplace coaching: meta-analysis and recommendations. Frontiers in Psychology, 2023. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37881215
- Dyrbye LN et al. Coaching intervention for physician well-being. JAMA Internal Medicine, 2019. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/31380892
- Dyrbye LN et al. Coaching and surgeon well-being trial. Annals of Surgery, 2023. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36000783
- CIPD: Coaching and mentoring, factsheet. www.cipd.org/uk/knowledge/factsheets/coaching-mentoring-factsheet
Written by Stuart Downing. Last reviewed 26 October 2026. Facts are checked against the sources above; nothing here describes a real client.






