Key takeaways
- Most difficult conversations go wrong through delay, vagueness or loss of control, not because the message itself was wrong.
- Prepare the facts, the effect and the single outcome you need before you book the meeting.
- Say the issue in the first minute; long warm-ups raise anxiety on both sides.
- Describe behaviour and impact, not character, and then listen properly to the other person's account.
- In a 2025 Acas survey, 94% of managers' conflict with direct reports concerned capability and performance.
- End with an agreed next step and confirm it in writing within a day.
What makes a conversation at work difficult?
A conversation becomes difficult when the stakes are high, emotions are likely to run strong and the two people may see the facts differently. Performance problems, complaints about behaviour, turning down a request, redundancy and conflict between colleagues all fit that description. So does pushing back on your own boss or chair.
These conversations are part of the job for anyone responsible for other people. Acas guidance written for line managers describes the ability to talk about sensitive, emotive issues as an integral part of effective management. In my communication coaching, they are among the most common things leaders bring.
Acas research shows how often they arise. In its 2025 survey of conflict at work, managers who reported conflict with their direct reports said it was almost always about capability and performance: 94% of cases. That is the conversation most leaders dread, and the one most worth learning to do well.
Why do leaders put off difficult conversations?
Leaders put off hard conversations because the discomfort is immediate and the cost of delay is spread out and easy to ignore. Each week of waiting feels safer than the meeting, until the problem has grown and the conversation is harder still.
- Fear of the other person's reaction, especially tears or anger.
- Worry about damaging a relationship or being disliked.
- Uncertainty about the facts, or about the policy.
- A belief that the problem might sort itself out.
- Having let it go too long already, which feels embarrassing to admit.
- A personal habit of avoiding conflict, sometimes linked to people-pleasing.
The 2025 Acas survey found that nearly one in five people who experienced conflict took no action at all, including some managers in conflict with their own reports. Acas notes that unaddressed issues can stay latent and resurface later. If avoidance is a long-standing pattern for you, the guide to people-pleasing may explain why.
How do you prepare for a difficult conversation?
Prepare by getting clear on three things: what has happened, why it matters and what you need to change. Preparation takes twenty minutes and makes the difference between a focused conversation and a rambling one.
- Check you are the right person.Acas suggests asking first whether this is your problem to raise. Most performance, conduct and absence issues sit with the line manager, but some belong with HR or someone more senior.
- Gather the facts.Specific examples with dates, what was said or done and the effect. Leave out rumour and interpretation.
- Check the policy.If the issue touches performance, conduct, absence or a grievance, read the relevant procedure so you do not promise something you cannot deliver.
- Decide the outcome you need.One sentence: what must be different after this conversation, and by when.
- Write your opening.Two or three sentences that state the issue plainly. Say them aloud once beforehand.
- Anticipate the response.Think about what the other person might say or feel, and what you might not know about their situation.
- Book the right setting.Private, unhurried, with no interruptions and enough time to finish properly.

How do you start a difficult conversation?
Start by naming the issue within the first minute, calmly and specifically. A long warm-up of small talk or praise makes the other person anxious and leaves the real message sounding like an afterthought.
Opening lines that work tend to be short and factual:
- I want to talk about the last three project deadlines, which were missed.
- I need to raise something about the meeting on Tuesday and how it went.
- I have had a complaint about comments made in the team channel, and I want to hear your side.
- I cannot approve the request, and I want to explain why and what I can offer.
- I think the way the two of you are working together is affecting the team, and I want to understand what is going on.
Then stop talking and let the other person respond. The silence can feel long, but it is often the moment the conversation turns from a statement into a discussion.
What should you say during a difficult conversation?
Say what happened, what effect it had and what needs to change, and spend at least as long listening as speaking. Keep the focus on behaviour and its impact, never on character. A structure keeps you steady when emotions rise.
| Stage | Aim | Example wording |
|---|---|---|
| Issue | Name the problem plainly | The last three reports arrived after the deadline. |
| Impact | Explain why it matters | That meant the client update went out late each time. |
| Their view | Understand what is going on | What has been happening from your side? |
| Options | Look for solutions together | What would help you hit the deadline next month? |
| Agreement | Settle a clear next step | So the next report comes to me by noon on the 5th, and I will check in on the 1st. |
| Follow-up | Make it real | I will email a summary of this today. |
The Acas guide on challenging conversations describes the key as control: of the situation, through clear boundaries; of your emotions; and of the action you plan to take. It also warns that managers with good intentions often prolong or intensify a problem instead of resolving it. Knowing when to widen a conversation and when to close it down is a skill that improves with practice.
If there is a conversation you have been putting off, a free 30-minute call is a good place to plan it.
Book a free 30-minute callHow do you handle tears, anger or silence?
Handle strong emotions by acknowledging them, pausing and then returning to the issue. Emotion is a normal response to hard news. Your job is to stay calm and respectful without abandoning the purpose of the meeting.
Tears
Offer a moment, water or a short break. Say that you can see this is hard. Then, when the person is ready, carry on. Ending the meeting every time someone is upset teaches both of you to avoid the subject.
Anger
Keep your own voice low and slow. Acknowledge the feeling without agreeing with every claim. If the anger escalates into shouting or threats, end the meeting calmly and arrange to continue another time, with HR present if needed.
Silence
Silence often means the person is thinking or shocked. Ask an open question, such as what is going through their mind, and wait. Avoid filling the gap with more explanation.
Assertiveness and confidence
This one-minute video sets out how I help with assertiveness: saying no, holding your ground in a disagreement and asking for what you need. I work on the beliefs behind the people-pleasing, and hypnotherapy is available as an option if it suits you.
Captions are available on YouTube.
Staying steady under that kind of pressure is partly about assertiveness: saying clearly what you need while respecting the other person. The article on how to say no at work covers the same skill from another angle.
What should you do after a difficult conversation?
Afterwards, confirm what was agreed in writing within a day, do what you promised and check in on the date you set. Follow-up is where most difficult conversations succeed or fail; without it, people assume nothing has really changed.
- Send a short, neutral summary of the issue, the agreement and the next date.
- Keep your own private note of what was said, especially if it may become formal.
- Notice and acknowledge improvement quickly when it happens.
- If nothing changes, hold a second conversation and consider formal routes.
- Reflect on your own part: what you would do differently next time.
If a working relationship has broken down badly, mediation can help. Acas describes it as a voluntary, confidential process in which an impartial mediator helps both sides agree how to work together in future. Separately, the guide to handling a toxic workplace as a leader covers situations where the problem is wider than one person.
How do you have a difficult conversation with your boss or board?
With someone more senior, the same principles apply, with more attention to timing and framing. Lead with the business consequence, bring evidence and a proposed solution, and ask for a decision or a next step rather than simply registering concern.
Senior leaders often find upward conversations harder than downward ones, because the power runs the other way and the stakes for their own career feel higher. Rehearsing the opening line and the likely objections helps. So does deciding in advance what you will do if the answer is no.
These conversations come up often in coaching with directors and senior managers. If the conversation concerns handing work to a colleague, the article on delegating without losing control helps set it up well.
How coaching helps with difficult conversations
Coaching helps you prepare, rehearse and review. In a session, you can say the opening line aloud, hear how it lands and adjust it before the real meeting. Afterwards, you can debrief honestly and plan the follow-up.
I have worked with clients since 2016, and my training covers NLP alongside clinical hypnotherapy and psychotherapy. That mix helps with the anxiety many people feel before confrontation as well as with the practical wording. My leadership coaching often includes this work, and packages include message support so you can check in just before a hard meeting.
Sessions run in person at 1 Harley Street or Edgbaston, or online. You can book a free 30-minute call to describe the conversation you are facing, and the article on how to handle criticism helps if you expect pushback.
Sources
- Acas: Challenging conversations and how to manage them. www.acas.org.uk/acas-guide-to-challenging-conversations-and-how-to-manage-them
- Acas research: conflict at work in Great Britain, 2025 survey findings. www.acas.org.uk/conflict-at-work-why-it-happens-and-how-people-try-to-resolve-it
- Acas: What mediation is and how it can help. www.acas.org.uk/mediation
Written by Stuart Downing. Last reviewed 26 October 2026. Facts are checked against the sources above; nothing here describes a real client.






